Study Programmes 2015-2016
PHIL0010-1  
History of contemporary philosophy
Duration :
45h Th
Number of credits :
Bachelor in ancient languages and literatures : classics5
Bachelor in ancient languages and literatures : classics5
Bachelor in information and communication5
Bachelor in information and communication5
Bachelor in modern languages and literatures : German, Dutch and English5
Bachelor in modern languages and literatures : German, Dutch and English5
Bachelor in history of art and archaeology : general5
Bachelor in history of art and archaeology : general5
Bachelor in history5
Bachelor in history5
Bachelor in modern languages and literatures : general5
Bachelor in modern languages and literatures : general5
Bachelor in history of art and archaeology : musicology5
Bachelor in history of art and archaeology : musicology5
Bachelor in ancient languages and literatures : Oriental studies5
Bachelor in ancient languages and literatures : Oriental studies5
Bachelor in philosophy5
Bachelor in philosophy5
Bachelor in French and Romance languages and literatures : general3
Bachelor in French and Romance languages and literatures : general5
Bachelor in French and Romance languages and literatures : general5
Master in philosophy (120 ECTS)5
Master in philosophy (60 ECTS)5
Lecturer :
Arnaud Dewalque
Language(s) of instruction :
French language
Organisation and examination :
Teaching in the second semester
Units courses prerequisite and corequisite :
Prerequisite or corequisite units are presented within each program
Course contents :
According to a common picture, the world we live in may be seen as a set of physical (or physical-cum-mental) entities which exist in space-time continuum and causally interact. It is uncontroversial that one task on the philosophical agenda is to analyse this common picture of the world, and one way of doing so certainly is by clarifying the meaning of the relevant metaphysical concepts: "existence", "physical", "mental", "thing", "space", "time", "cause", and the like. But how are we supposed to clarify all these concepts? 
The british philosopher David Hume (1711-1776) suggested that such a clarification is best obtained by identifying, for each concept, the experience it comes from, that is its "empirical origin". Unfortunately, his attempt to establish the empirical origine of the concept fo "cause" prooved to be unsuccessful. As a result, the german philosopher Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) concluded that our metaphysical concepts were not experience-based and were a priori. Yet, what does it mean exactly, for a concept, to be a priori? Are-there really apriorical concepts? Why should we believe that it is so? What if Kant's view would eventually amount to simply drop the so-called "problem of Hume", rather than solving it? Maybe there is another, more promising solution? Maybe the experience we have of our own mental states - the mental experience - is a good candidate when it comes to identify the origin of our metaphysical concepts, as it has been suggested by the austro-german philosopher Franz Brentano (1838-1917)? Could-it be that solving Hume's problem therefore implies something like a descriptive analysis of our own mental states, a "descriptive psychology"?
Addressing these questions, the course aims at exploring the roots of the present-day philosophical scene in late nineteen- and early twentieth-century Austrian-German philosophy. It places the focus on the interplay between philosophy and psychology.
Learning outcomes of the course :
By the end of the course, listeners are supposed to:
  • master a series of historical informations about the nineteen-century Austrian-German philosophy.
  • be able to look in a critical manner to the historiography of this period as it is available in classical manuals of the history of Western philosophy.
  • be aware of a small number of controversial problems which have had a crucial role to play in the birth of contemporary philosophy.
Prerequisite knowledge and skills :
At least one Philosophy course.
Planned learning activities and teaching methods :
The course involve a series of lectures, in most cases with powerpoint presentation. There is no syllabus available. Each lesson will be based on a short texte which will be made available in advance. Students in philosophy are asked to chooze three of the set texts and to write three short reading reports. The list of the texts and the schedule will be made available at the beginning of the course and can be downloaded by following the link below.
Mode of delivery (face-to-face ; distance-learning) :
Duration: 45 hours 2nd term, on Tuesdays. Lectures take place in the room "Philo II" (main building, 2nd floor). First lecture: Tuesday February 2 2016. See http://cipl82.philo.ulg.ac.be/horaires
Recommended or required readings :
A series of suggested readings will be made available at the first sessions (see schedule). The following list of recommended books may be helpful for students wishing to delve more deeply into the topic of the course:
- On the historical background of German-Austrian philosophy during the second half of the nineteen century:
  • L. Freuler, La Crise de la philosophie au XIXe siècle, Paris, Vrin, 1997 (available at the ULg Philosophy library: 43FRE).
  • M. Heidegger, "Genèse et première percée de la recherche phénoménologique", dans Prolégomènes à l'histoire du concept de temps, French translation. A. boutot, Paris, Gallimard, 2006, pp. 33-51 (50HEI.BOU).
- On the Brentano School:
  • D. Fisette and G. Fréchette, "Le Legs de Brentano", from the collection A l'école de Brentano. De Würzbourg à Vienne, Pars, Vrin, 2007, pp. 13-160 (45BRE.FIS).
  • L. Albertazzi, M. Libardi and R. Poli (eds.), The School of Franz Brentano, Dordrecht, Kluwer, 1996 (45BRE.ALB).
- On neo-Kantianism:
  • E. Dufour, Les Néokantiens. Valeur et vérité, Paris, Vrin, 2003.
  • M. Ferrari, Retours à Kant. Introduction au néo-kantisme, French translation, Th. Loisel, Paris, Cerf, 2001 (42KAN.FER).
Assessment methods and criteria :
For students in Philosophy, the assessment will be made up of two parts:


  • Part I: a series of reading reports (40% of the final grade) wich will be submitted during the classes. The schedule will be made available at the beginning of the course.
A 'reading report' is a short text (2 pages) presented as an analysis of a piece of reading. Each report will cover an article or chapter from the reading list given at the beginning of the course. It will be made up of three parts: (1) What is the main thesis of the author? (2) What are his arguments? (3) Is his position convincing? The aim is to develop the student's abilities of reading, analyzing and writting. The brevity of the reports makes it necessary to sharpen the focus and get to the essential. The compliance with stylistic and typographic rules (see Methodology of Philosophy, PHIL0005-2) is required. The criteria for assessment are: 1. understanding of the subject, 2. clarity and quality of language; 3. structure and internal coherence. Failure to comply with basic formal conventions (spelling, formatting, quotations, etc) as well as unmotivated delay will be automatically sanctioned by penalty points.


  • Part II: Final oral examination (60% of the final grade) during the June session.
The exam will take the form of a short interview during which students should demonstrate their knowledge of the subject matter covered in class and understanding of the course reading material. This involves, for example, situating an author in the philosophical landscape of this period, describing the main features of a philosophical school, explaining a concept, commenting upon an extract of text covered in class or developing a line of argument analyzed during the year.
For students from other disciplines: oral examination only.
Work placement(s) :
Organizational remarks :
All students enrolled in History and Romance Languages and Literature wishing to follow this course as an option are welcome.
Contacts :
Teacher Arnaud Dewalque Philosophy Department 7, Place du 20-août, Building A1/2nd floor B-4000 Liège Phone 0032 (4) 366 55 93 E-mail a.dewalque@ulg.ac.be
Items online :
Trees of the neo-Kantian and Brentanian Schools
Overview
  • of the "Back to Kant"-Movement
  • of the Brentano School and its ramifications
See "Teaching Material" on my personal webpage.
Slides - 1. Introduction, Hume's problem
1. Introduction, Hume's problem
Slides - 2. Kant and physiological neo-Kantianism, Neo-Kantianism and Platonism
2nd class: February, 23, 2016

- Kant and physiological neo-Kantianism

- Neo-Kantianism and Platonism
Slides - 3. Neo-Kantianism and Platonism (continuation), Nietzsche
3rd class: March, 1, 2016

- Neo-Kantianism and Platonism (continuation)

- Nietzsche
Slides - 4. Nietzsche (continuation), Bolzano
4th class: March, 8, 2016

- Nietzsche (continuation)

- Bolzano's anti-Kantianism
Slides - 5. Bolzano (continuation), Brentano
5th class: March, 15, 2016

- Bolzano's anti-Kantianism (continuation)

- Brentano's anti-Kantianism
Slides - 6. Brentano (continuation)
6th class: March, 22, 2016

- Brentano's anti-Kantianism (continuation)